Openmed - Medizinische Hilfen - anonym und kostenfrei.
Unsichtbare Welten
Tätigkeitsbericht 2006
Vergessene Krisen
Arte Fernsehspot
EU Inititive: Ärzte der Welt fordert Abschiebestopp für schwerkranke Asylsuchende

Directive on common standards and procedures in Member States for returning illegally staying third-country nationals : request for modification

To the Members of European Parliament :

Our attention has been drawn to a new directive published on September 1st 2005 on common standards and procedures in Member States for returning illegally staying third-country nationals. The directive is about to be adopted in the coming weeks or months by the European parliament and the Council.

We are concerned  that the directive takes into account the health conditions of migrants only in terms of ensuring that they do not die during transportation to their country of origin .

We would like to emphasise 2 facts :
-    We are strongly against considering  health issues from a cost point of view, which is to say only to avoid extra costs for transport companies having to deal with a dying passenger
-    One of the strong common basis of European Union is to refuse death sentence : we all agree with this fundamental principle. But when a European country  returns a person with an illness which cannot be cured in his country of origin, it is just a postponed administrative death sentence (this does concern HIV but also Hypertension, cancers, diabetes…).

This is the reason why we are asking your full support to make sure that the health and lives of ill migrants are not put under threat as a result of an administrative procedure. As such, we are asking you to amend paragraph 5 of the article 6  " Return decision  " of the chapter II " Termination of illegal stay "  by adding the following text as shown below:

Chapter II Termination of illegal stay
Article 6 Return decision

5/ Member States may, at any moment decide to grant an autonomous residence permit or another authorisation offering a right to stay for compassionate, humanitarian or other reasons to a third-country national staying illegally on their territory.
Text to be added in the middle of the paragraph :
For any person suffering from a serious illness, Member States grant an autonomous residence permit or another authorisation conferring a right to stay to receive adequate access to healthcare, unless it can be proved that he/she can receive appropriate treatment and medical care in his/her country of origin.

In this event no return decision shall be issued or where a return decision has already been issued, it shall be withdrawn.



Extract from the directive, chapter 2, article 8 :
« …
2. Member States shall postpone the execution of a removal order in the following circumstances, for as long as those circumstances prevail:
a) inability of the third-country national to travel or to be transported to the country of return due to his or her physical state or mental capacity ;
 … »




Impressum